With The “Walking While Trans” Repeal Vote, Advocates Hope Legislation Includes Sealing Past Convictions


After years of stress from activists, the New York State legislature is anticipated to repeal the “loitering for the needs of prostitution” regulation this week.  

The statute was carried out in 1976, and has been utilized by police to disproportionately goal Black and Latinx trans ladies for suspected intercourse work. Transgender activists coined the time period  “strolling whereas trans” over their shared harassment beneath the statute. Authorized students have known as it a “gendered stop-and-frisk.” 

Whereas its tough to acquire knowledge on what number of trans ladies have been impacted beneath this statute because of police misgendering, anecdotal surveys from Amnesty Worldwide and the Human Rights Marketing campaign recommend transgender individuals have been most impacted by the statute. In response to HRC, greater than 60% of transgender New Yorkers have skilled police harassment. Additional, the HRC says 83% of individuals charged with loitering for the aim of prostitution have been Black ladies. In 2017, the NYPD did loosen their enforcement, nevertheless some boroughs, like Queens, noticed an uptick in arrests after the patrol information adjustments have been in place. 

What’s Totally different This Time? 

That is the third time since 2017 {that a} repeal proposal has had momentum within the state legislature. The distinction in lawmaker help this time round might be attributed to renewed stress from final 12 months’s George Floyd protests, which drew nationwide consideration to systemic racial injustice. A supermajority within the state legislature additionally helps, as does some vocalized enthusiasm from Governor Cuomo. 

That is the primary model of the invoice to name for the sealing of prior convictions, which might forestall a conviction from being made out there to the general public and most employers. The conviction nonetheless exists, however generally won’t be reported as a part of a background test for employment, housing, schooling, and immigration. 

“This offers us a method for having the ability to file for employment and really feel as if we may file for housing and never get fearful about getting evicted due to our background,” mentioned T.S Candii, a trans-rights activist, who has been a vocal chief within the Strolling Whereas Trans repeal, after being stopped by police in 2017 within the Bronx whereas smoking a cigarette exterior. 

An individual’s first “loitering for the needs of prostitution’’ (LLP) cost is taken into account a violation. Nevertheless, not like all New York violations and visitors infractions (besides a ‘driving whereas capacity impaired’ cost),  an LLP violation just isn’t robotically sealed after a 12 months. 

“Though this isn’t a prostitution statute…as a result of this has the phrase ‘prostitution’’ hooked up to it, it’s thought of—by the individuals [who] maintain the keys to needed elements in life—as extra critical,” mentioned Jared Trujillo, the coverage director for the New York Civil Liberties Union. 

Whereas in some instances people with entry to authorized help and cash can petition the courts to have their LLP violation sealed, nearly all of individuals charged beneath the statute don’t have that privilege. “By having this easy violation as one thing that by no means seals, you erect one other barrier for actually no purpose, apart from poor legislative drafting that led this regulation to be handled in a different way than every other violation within the ebook,” mentioned Trujillo. 


The affect of an LLP violation or the potential of 1 is usually a great burden on immigrants and asylum seekers.

Aneiry Zapata is a 24 year-old Garifuna transgender girl from Honduras. Zapata didn’t really feel comfy talking to her immigration standing, however she has labored as an advocate for trans-asylum seekers within the metropolis since she moved to Queens 5 years in the past. 

Final 12 months, Zapata known as the police whereas she was in her residence along with her mother’s boyfriend as a result of he was appearing aggressive in direction of her. Talking in Spanish, she mentioned that law enforcement officials arrived 4 hours later, “I used to be in my pajamas and so they requested me if I used to be a intercourse employee and so they didn’t imagine that I used to be in my very own home.” Zapata mentioned she had heard of pals being arrested by police off the road as a result of they suspected them of intercourse work. Since being profiled as a intercourse employee, Zapata says she needs a few of the safety that comes with sealing a violation if she have been to be arrested for loitering. 

New York Metropolis’s sanctuary coverage prohibits native regulation enforcement from collaborating with Immigration and Customs Enforcement officers in most circumstances. Nevertheless, beneath U.S immigration regulation, a prostitution-related cost may very well be thought of an aggravated felony or a ‘crime of ethical turpitude.’ This might result in deportation, along with being barred from getting asylum. Having an LLP cost sealed, or expunged, may re-open up the asylum course of for some trans ladies immigrants who may face persecution or dying of their former nation. 

In Queens, greater than half of the LLP arrests occurred in 2018 amongst a big inhabitants of trans-women immigrants. The Caribbean Equality Mission helps dozens of trans-asylum seekers within the borough. “We work with purchasers that genuinely possess a sort of concern that they’re going to be deported or denied asylum based mostly on in the event that they keep out too late and a police officer reaches out to them,” mentioned coverage advisor for the CEP Kadeem Robinson.

Resulting from this concern of deportation throughout the group, Robinson believes  that prior convictions needs to be expunged, and never simply sealed. “There needs to be no debate round expunging—frankly—the information of such a regulation that we all know has been used to focus on trans immigrants,” they mentioned. (Robinson makes use of they/them pronouns and identifies as nonbinary.) Nevertheless, in some immigration and asylum instances, the federal authorities could not settle for the state’s expungement of legal information and the identical might be true on the subject of sealing. 

In December 2020, the New York Metropolis Council paired their decision for the Strolling Whereas Trans repeal with a further decision calling on sealing convictions. Final week, Brooklyn District Lawyer Eric Gonzalez introduced that he can be dismissing “all excellent prostitution-related warrants,” or about 262 in whole with 79 being loitering for the needs of prostitution arrests. In a press release, Gonzalez additionally known as on lawmakers, “I’m asking the legislature to expunge previous prostitution convictions so they won’t maintain individuals again from alternatives for a greater future.”

State Senator Brad Hoylman, who sponsored the invoice within the Senate, mentioned he hoped that sealing prior convictions would stay a part of the  invoice. And Assemblywoman Amy Paulin, who’s  sponsoring the invoice within the Meeting, famous that it was after talking with activists that the sealing language was put within the laws, so she is glad it’s included. 

Activists might be ready to see what occurs after the ultimate flooring vote on Tuesday within the State Senate.

“No podemos hacer lucha en la calle si no podemos andar en la calle,” mentioned Zapata. Translation: “We are able to’t struggle on the street, if we will’t stroll on the street.”