Tenant Advocates Say New Emergency Rental Assistance Program Might Not Be Reaching The Most Vulnerable New Yorkers


Tenant advocates say the $2.7 billion federally-funded emergency rental help program geared toward serving to struggling New Yorkers behind on their lease as a result of pandemic won’t be reaching the residents who want it probably the most.

New Yorkers began making use of for this system on June 1st. The company in command of the Emergency Rental Help Program (ERAP), the Workplace of Momentary and Incapacity Help (OTDA), obtained 119,209 functions by the top of June, with the 91,457 coming from New York Metropolis (the company says some functions is likely to be duplicates).

However advocates say issues with the web utility portal might be stopping the lowest-income, immigrants and senior New Yorkers from efficiently submitting functions, including additional stress in paying their again lease.

“I concern we won’t attain the very communities that the laws particularly needed to achieve, primarily folks underneath 50% of the realm median earnings, survivors of home violence, survivors of intercourse trafficking and folks dwelling with disabilities,” stated Jack Newton, director of the general public advantages unit at Bronx Authorized Companies. “I believe that can proceed to be an issue within the weeks to return.”

Bronx Authorized Companies is one in all 29 non-profits that despatched a letter to OTDA earlier this month asking the company to handle the issues individuals are experiencing: the problem of amassing all the required paperwork and importing them, a difficulty that has ceaselessly tripped up tenants as a result of functions can’t be saved and resumed; “error” messages that drive tenants to exit and restart an utility; insufficient translations of the details about this system into different languages; and needing to have an electronic mail deal with to submit an utility.

Justin Mason, a spokesperson for OTDA, stated they “are addressing any technical points promptly and as they’re encountered,” and are reviewing the letter.

“The company has undertaken an unprecedented effort to ascertain partnerships with native governments throughout the state and welcomes any enter we obtain from community-based organizations—particularly these teams actively concerned in serving to New Yorkers apply for this crucial help,” he stated.

Timothy Johnson, 59, stated he and his accomplice, who dwell in a two-bedroom condominium within the Morrisania part of the Bronx with their two daughters, made 5 unsuccessful makes an attempt in making use of for this system. Johnson stated their landlord advised them they owe $11,000 in again lease (an quantity they dispute) from through the pandemic. He has tried to use on his cellphone as a result of he doesn’t have entry to a pc, however stated he bumped into points importing paperwork.

“It is complicated,” Johnson stated. “It tells you to add paperwork and it would not inform you which paperwork to add. You actually must be computer-savvy to know the best way to fill this out.”

Landlord teams have additionally expressed dissatisfaction with the rollout of this system. Jay Martin, the manager director on the Neighborhood Housing Enchancment Program, which represents 4,000 property homeowners within the metropolis, stated probably the most profitable landlords are those who’ve been scheduling 30-minute appointments with tenants of their places of work and assigning their workers to help with functions, which he sees because the state’s failure to ascertain a user-friendly utility course of.

“You possibly can go on Amazon, you’ll be able to order rest room paper and have it at your own home in 24 hours,” he stated. “However after we’re speaking a few multi-billion greenback program from the federal government to assist maintain folks of their houses and to maintain the housing market from collapsing, we won’t even determine a approach to maintain the web site from not crashing.”

Officers say households with earnings at or under 80% of the realm median earnings (AMI)—$95,450 for a household of 4 within the metropolis, as an example—can stand up to 12 months of rental and utility arrears funds. In the course of the first 30 days of this system, OTDA was prioritizing functions from lower-income households incomes 50% of AMI which have no less than one member who’s unemployed, a veteran, or a home violence sufferer. Now, the cash will likely be distributed on a first-come, first-served foundation, with the objective of serving between 170,000 and 200,000 households throughout the state. The OTDA spokesman stated they anticipate the primary funds to exit “within the coming weeks.”

Whereas noting that’s an essential objective, advocates stated they’re additionally fearful in regards to the lack of extra granular information about the place functions for this system are coming from. Ellen Davidson, workers lawyer on the Authorized Help Society, stated they’ve requested OTDA to launch zip code and income-level information on tenants who’ve utilized for this system to find out whether or not outreach efforts have labored and who’s being not noted.

“When any of those packages are created, oftentimes you see the very best earnings, most educated folks making use of earlier than probably the most weak,” she stated. “Generally it takes unconventional outreach, directed outreach to guarantee that everybody is aware of in regards to the utility.”

Nohemi Rojas, 36, stated she benefited from that type of outreach. Though it took three makes an attempt (she stated she was lacking paperwork), final month, she submitted her utility, with the assistance from the group Make the Highway New York. She and her husband misplaced their jobs through the pandemic and couldn’t pay lease and utility payments for his or her condominium in Elmhurst, Queens, for six months. They amassed practically $14,000 in missed funds. Now, she stated, all she will be able to do is wait to see if her utility will get authorised.

“I really feel pleased and suspenseful on the similar time,” she stated.