Queens DA Says Cop Accused Of Kneeling On Man’s Neck Didn’t Violate Chokehold Ban


The NYPD officer who was captured on video showing to kneel on a Black man’s neck throughout a January arrest in Queens is not going to be prosecuted, Queens District Legal professional Melinda Katz mentioned Friday.

In a press release, Katz didn’t title the officer however the Queens Eagle recognized the person as Officer Thomas Montario of the 113th Precinct.

Montario was a part of a gaggle of responding officers who arrested Lengthy Island resident Sircarlyle Arnold on January 2nd in Jamaica, Queens, on misdemeanor reckless endangerment for allegedly working an unlawful ATV. He additionally dedicated 4 different car site visitors offenses, in response to police.

In bodycam footage launched by the DA’s workplace, witnesses yell at Montario as he kneels on Arnold’s higher physique as he’s mendacity on the bottom along with his arms behind his again.

“Have a look at his knee! Have a look at his knee!” a witness shouts whereas one other individual yells “Take your knee off!” The video launched by the DA’s workplace doesn’t clearly present the place Montario’s knee is on Arnold’s physique, however one other cellphone video appears to point out that he’s kneeling on Arnold’s neck.

The incident drew comparisons to the killing of George Floyd by Minneapolis police officer Derek Chauvin, who knelt on Floyd’s neck for greater than 9 minutes till he stopped respiration. Chauvin is now on trial for homicide.

Nonetheless, Katz mentioned there was “inadequate proof” that Montario used an illegal methodology of restraint on Arnold, and couldn’t convey a case in opposition to Montario beneath a chokehold ban handed by the Metropolis Council within the aftermath of Floyd’s dying, which makes it a misdemeanor for cops to make use of a number of strategies of restraint, together with kneeling on an individual’s again or neck, or limiting the circulate of air by blocking their windpipe, in the midst of an arrest.

Katz mentioned “Whereas I absolutely help the spirit of laws that prioritizes police accountability and thereby promotes neighborhood engagement, the weather of AC 10-181 (the chokehold ban) should not glad on this case.”

She added, “Particularly, in an effort to fulfill the statute, certainly one of two issues should be made out which the proof doesn’t present occurred right here: The legislation requires a discovering that the officer concerned restricted the circulate of air or blood by both compressing Mr. Arnold’s windpipe or the carotid arteries on both sides of his neck. There could possibly be no such discovering beneath the information right here. Neither did the proof help a discovering that air or blood circulate have been restricted by sitting, kneeling or standing on the neck in a fashion that compresses the diaphragm.”

Katz mentioned her workplace carried out a “thorough investigation that included session with two medical specialists and an NYPD knowledgeable in Bodily Coaching and Techniques, interviews with a number of officers and Sircarlyle Arnold, and in depth evaluation of NYPD Physique Worn Digicam footage.”

Prosecutors have beforehand mentioned the bodycams worn by Montario and different arresting officers have been “broken throughout the arrest” by being dislodged and probably run over by automotive, making the footage unusable, the Queens Eagle reported.

Arnold mentioned in a January interview that he was taking part in a gaggle ride-out for a not too long ago deceased good friend when he was arrested and had no intention of defying the officers’ orders. He mentioned he was dismounting his quad bike when he was thrown to the bottom unexpectedly by a number of officers.

“You guys handled me like this for no motive in spite of everything these items that simply went on?” Arnold mentioned on the time.

The costs in opposition to Arnold have been dismissed by Katz’s workplace, the Queens Eagle reported. NYPD spokesperson Detective Sophia Mason mentioned the division’s “inner investigation is ongoing.”