Mapping The Clusters of NYPD Officers Repeatedly Accused Of Misconduct


Each time a civilian recordsdata a criticism about an encounter with NYPD officers, the Civilian Criticism Evaluation Board investigates. The impartial police watchdog determines which officers had been accused of extreme power, improper searches, or different types of misconduct, and which of them, if any, stood by because the interplay unfolded. Every criticism investigation thus generates invisible hyperlinks tying collectively the small group of officers who had been there that day.

Combining lots of of hundreds of those hyperlinks collectively, an enormous community emerges, revealing tightly-knit clusters of officers that civilians have repeatedly accused of abuse. With the assistance of impartial information journalist EJ Fox, WNYC/Gothamist mapped this community utilizing a dataset of civilian complaints obtained via a Freedom of Info Regulation request. 

The traces on the maps above and under are distinctive civilian criticism co-occurrences tying collectively pairs of officers who’ve been named collectively in a criticism investigation, both as witnesses or as topics of allegations. The officers themselves are represented by circles or nodes, that are sized primarily based on the variety of ties they must different officers. 

The tie rely incorporates each the preliminary connection between two officers recognized in a criticism investigation collectively, and every subsequent criticism investigation through which the identical officer pair seems once more. For instance, Daniel Pantaleo, who was fired in 2019 after an investigation into his deadly chokehold of Eric Garner, had 184 community ties with 27 different officers, placing him inside the prime 150 NYPD officers within the dataset which covers criticism incidents going again to 2010.

The ties are primarily based on criticism allegations that had been substantiated or through which the investigation ended inconclusively, comparable to when the CCRB couldn’t get in contact with a complainant or couldn’t show or disprove the allegation. WNYC/Gothamist excluded allegations that the CCRB deemed to be unfounded or through which the officers’ actions had been deemed to be justified. Lacking from the dataset are officers who had been accused of misconduct, however whom the CCRB couldn’t determine or whose investigations had been resolved via mediation.

Fox additionally coloured distinct “communities” recognized inside the community by an algorithm from Gephi, an information visualization program. Unsurprisingly, many of those community communities are composed of officers who frolicked in the identical precincts or items. The community maps all through this piece solely title officers who’ve had a minimum of one allegation towards them substantiated by the CCRB. (For extra on the information methodology, learn EJ Fox’s in-depth clarification right here.

The ensuing visualization under illustrates the extent to which controversial police conduct is commonly a bunch conduct. The next is an explorable map of the community of officers tied to criticism incidents since 2010, filtered all the way down to solely embrace officers with a minimum of 99 ties to different officers. (Word: WNYC/Gothamist filtered the information down to point out solely actors with giant numbers of ties for ease of visualization. Due to the filtering, you’ll not see the entire officer nodes related to comparatively giant, seen officer nodes. However you will note connections to different comparatively giant nodes within the community.)

(The interactive graphic exhibits a filtered model of the community of civilian complaints towards NYPD officers over the past ten years. It solely contains the small subset of officers within the information who every have a minimum of 99 ties and the names of these officers who’ve had a substantiated allegation of misconduct. Community visualization by EJ Fox.)

“Police misconduct can, after all, occur from a solo drawback officer,” stated Andrew Papachristos, a sociologist at Northwestern College, who has co-authored quite a few research on networks of police misconduct. “However the discovering of those clusters of misconduct, these clusters of complaints, suggests that there is one thing that is truly taking place within the formal and casual networks of cops.”

He added that the folks an officer is related to can have an effect on how they “really feel, suppose, and do”—with unhealthy and even violent conduct being an end result that networks will help clarify.

The NYPD didn’t reply to requests for remark.

In a press release, CCRB Chair Fred Davie stated his company can study from community analyses like this, notably because it research how one can examine racial profiling and different types of bias-based policing. 

“The NYPD should take civilian complaints of misconduct significantly as a result of New Yorkers who expertise police misconduct deserve accountability,” stated Davie. “This evaluation is helpful for exploring the methods through which complaints of misconduct amongst a small group of officers uncover bigger, systemic points inside the NYPD which have remained unaddressed.”

The Community Outliers

The community dataset exhibits appreciable variation on the power. Most officers, who had been named in criticism investigations with any colleagues in any respect since 2010, had been solely related to 5 colleagues or much less. Then again, the highest 9.35% of officers had been related to twenty or extra colleagues, and often these officers had quite a few repeat ties with a subset of these colleagues. 

Many of those highly-connected officers are on the heart of distinct communities within the community and have controversial histories. A number of had been disciplined or pushed off the power by the NYPD whereas a handful had been convicted of legal conduct.

One huge officer node in the course of a relatively-isolated mild blue cluster on the backside of the explorable, filtered community map represents a detective who not too long ago retired after he was seen on digital camera utilizing an alleged banned chokehold throughout an arrest in Inwood. 

A cluster showing officer Nunez in the center, with other officers connected to him


This remoted cluster cluster features a well-connected node representing an officer who was convicted for transporting medication in 2018.

EJ Fox

Two hops away from him in the identical community neighborhood stands one other giant node representing an officer who was caught in an NYPD sting transporting cocaine from the Bronx to Manhattan for an undercover officer posing as a drug supplier in 2018. That officer had 254 community ties with 29 distinctive officers within the interval Gothamist/WNYC analyzed. (Word: Most of those ties are usually not seen within the graphic above as a result of the explorable community map solely contains the small subset of officers within the information who every have a minimum of 99 ties).

Pantaleo, the officer who fatally choked Eric Garner, additionally pops up within the filtered community on the heart of a small mild yellow cluster on the far proper. His cluster is tied to a a lot bigger floating clump of officers largely from Staten Island.

This graphic shows Pantaleo connected to other officers who have substantiated complaints


This cluster from the filtered community map exhibits Daniel Pantaleo and several other different officers tied to him who themselves have many community ties.

EJ Fox

Traditionally, Papachristos notes, many police corruption and misconduct scandals in huge cities throughout the nation have centered on groups of officers, quite than solitary unhealthy actors. 

In Baltimore, an elite gun unit carried out a collection of spectacular robberies of drug sellers till they had been arrested by the FBI in 2017. In Nineties Los Angeles, anti-gang officers stole medication and framed residents, leading to quite a few overturned convictions.

“What occurs in these instances is you cowl for one another, you propose with one another,” Papachristos stated. Due to these group patterns, the sociologist asserts, it’s truthful for authorities to make use of community mapping to determine potential collective deviance. “You may get a glimpse of, probably, of us which are concerned in these kinds of crews of cops by doing these kinds of study,” he stated.

The officer ranked highest within the community—primarily based on his distinctive criticism appearances with some colleagues and repeat appearances with others—is Robert Martinez, a embellished sergeant who labored for almost twenty years in powerful assignments throughout Brooklyn. Martinez had greater than 600 community ties primarily based on his co-appearances in criticism investigations since 2010 with 63 different officers.

A graphic showing Martinez at the center of many relationships with officers with substantiated complaints


A detailed-up picture of among the officer nodes related to former seventy fifth precinct Sergeant Robert Martinez.

EJ Fox

In 2006, he and one other officer in an aggressive, plainclothes unit referred to as “Anti-Crime” had been named “Cops of the Month” for pulling over a person driving via Brooklyn with a van carrying over 600 kilos of marijuana. In 2014, Martinez received the division’s Police Fight Cross, its second highest medal, which is given for heroic acts throughout struggles with armed adversaries. In 2019, the sergeant acquired extra adulation for main a midnight crew of Anti-Crime officers, who arrested an alleged gang member in East New York with two handguns after responding to reviews of photographs being fired.

However with all of those accolades and high-profile arrests got here complaints from civilians towards Martinez and the plainclothes officers working with him.

In 2007, a 23-year-old Black resident in East Flatbush accused Martinez and a colleague of getting out of an unmarked automotive and pushing him up towards a wall, as a part of a search exterior his home. In a single interview with a CCRB investigator, the younger man claimed that, upon seeing the officers, he tried to stroll away and name his mom for assist. That’s when, the younger man alleged, Martinez positioned his elbow on his throat “making an attempt to wrestle” him.

Police didn’t make an arrest and the CCRB substantiated a power cost towards Martinez. But, the NYPD meted out no self-discipline, in response to CCRB data.

Six years later, whereas serving as a sergeant in East New York’s seventy fifth precinct, one other Black man accused Martinez of escalating a road search. 

In a civilian criticism, 33-year-old Desmon Goins claimed he had been warding off two different plainclothes officers who had been making an attempt to go looking his pockets with out explaining themselves, when Martinez stepped in and punched him within the face. 

The 2 officers then helped Martinez slam him to Goins to the bottom, in response to a lawsuit he later filed. As Goins lay on the pavement exterior his home, the swimsuit alleges, Martinez pressed his boot down onto his face, busting his lip. 

After the scuffle, police charged Goins with resisting arrest, however prosecutors dropped the fees and Goins filed a civilian criticism. After an investigation the NYPD docked Martinez ten trip days. 

In response to Goins’ subsequent lawsuit, the sergeant and different officers on the scene denied Goins’ brutality claims, in response to courtroom data. Town later settled with Goins for greater than $50,000

Within the years that adopted, Martinez continued to generate substantiated allegations for improper stops, searches, and utilizing foul language leading to minor, or no self-discipline. Within the meantime, a dense cluster of officers tied to him via civilian complaints step by step fashioned. 


(Above, year-by-year cumulative progress of the criticism community related to the seventy fifth precinct; crimson nodes are officers, blue nodes are incidents. For extra on this distinct manner of mapping, learn EJ Fox’s in-depth clarification right here.)

Martinez didn’t reply to repeated requests for remark submitted to union representatives and the attorneys who represented him in Goins’ lawsuit. CCRB data point out he left the power across the finish of 2019.

Large Nodes: A Measure of Affect or Exercise?

Lots of the greatest nodes within the community are officers like Martinez who labored for years in high-crime areas and in specialised items like narcotics or the Anti-Crime squads. NYPD Commissioner Dermot Shea phased out Anti-Crime final summer time exactly due to the groups’ controversial document.

Joseph Giacalone, a John Jay School adjunct professor and a former NYPD detective sergeant, factors out that division veterans, particularly those that keep on the road like sergeants, accumulate quite a few alternatives for civilian contact and subsequent complaints. He additionally identified that officers in combative and team-oriented assignments usually tend to generate criticism ties. 

“Any state of affairs the place there are tons of arrests, you’re going to have a lot of complaints,” Giacalone stated.  

However even accounting for variables like unit assignments, researchers have discovered that key officers can exert detrimental affect, spreading misconduct throughout their networks. Analyzing power criticism information in Chicago, Papachristos and several other different researchers discovered that officers working with a better proportion of colleagues with use of power histories had been extra prone to be concerned in future use-of-force complaints themselves.

WNYC/Gothamist was unable to do the same evaluation in New York Metropolis to evaluate potential peer affect as a result of exact historic information on officers’ entry and exit from NYPD items over their careers will not be at the moment out there. (WNYC/Gothamist requested the NYPD for this information and likewise has an excellent public data request looking for it.)

However a number of residents urged to WNYC/Gothamist that their experiences help the rivalry that officer misconduct might be viral. 

Screengrab from video showing an officer with facial hair and wearing a hat and in a blue Under Armor shirt with an NYPD badge hanging from around his neck on a street


Video exhibits an officer carrying a badge with Adnan Radoncic’s defend quantity telling a civilian to again up earlier than all of the sudden jerking his arm in direction of the digital camera.


On an April night final yr, Adegoke Atunbi stated he was making an attempt to document a police encounter he had stumbled upon on a road in East New York when an officer all of the sudden pushed away his digital camera and commenced assaulting him. Video exhibits an officer in a blue Below Armour shirt telling Atunbi to again up earlier than all of the sudden jerking his arm in direction of the digital camera. 

“He simply lunged at me, he grabbed me, punched me within the face, and threw me to the bottom, and a bunch of officers simply tackled me,” the medical provide firm proprietor claimed. 

The officer’s badge quantity within the video matches that of Adnan Radoncic, a sergeant within the seventy fifth Precinct, as The Brooklyn Paper first reported. 

Radnonic has been the topic of greater than a dozen civilian complaints and lawsuits over his profession, and is ranked because the fifth greatest node within the community map. Within the interval WNYC/Gothamist analyzed since 2010, the sergeant had accrued greater than 400 community ties unfold out between 68 colleagues. 

Network cluster map showing Adnan Radoncic's relationships are connected by other ties to Robert Martinez, as well as many others


A detailed-up picture of among the officer nodes related to former seventy fifth precinct Sergeant Adnan Radoncic.

EJ Fox

Atunbi asserted that Radoncic was a catalyst for a bunch assault on the road that day.

“As quickly as he grabbed me, all of the officers was palms on,” he stated. “It’s like they simply adopted his lead.”

Whereas he was on the bottom, Atunbi stated he felt a bunch of round ten officers on prime of him. He remembers being punched within the face and kicked within the head. 

“You’d have thought I had a rocket launcher in my hand, the way in which they tackled me to the bottom,” he continued. “All I had was my mobile phone.”

Atunbi is now suing the NYPD. After the encounter with police, he stated, he needed to have hip surgical procedure and continues to be going to bodily remedy to get better from his accidents.

“I can’t take two steps with out holding onto one thing attributable to this incident,” he stated, noting that he has to make use of a curler. “I can’t play with my youngsters. It has modified my life eternally.” 

Radoncic, who has acquired quite a few commendations for “meritorious” and “glorious” police obligation and made greater than ninety felony arrests over his profession, didn’t reply to requests for remark submitted to the Sergeants Benevolent Affiliation.

Coverage Implications

M.Okay. Kaishian, Senior Coverage Counsel for the Brooklyn Defender Companies, notes that the NYPD itself has the information essential to determine and take away officers who might be spreading misconduct throughout the power. 

“And but what occurs is the other, these clusters of misconduct and abuse are literally protected and additional and additional entrenched into the NYPD,” she stated. “And that’s as a result of they are surely emblematic of the NYPD’s tradition. They’re not an aberration.”

Even when sure officers type clusters merely due to the character of their assignments, that, too, needs to be worrying, Kaishian argued. “That’s not a type of policing that we needs to be tolerant of,” she stated. “If they’re making so many arrests, and due to this fact have so many victims, that’s nonetheless an issue.”

Giacalone, the adjunct professor and former detective sergeant, stated that repeated complaints are actually price trying into, particularly after investigators detect potential legal conduct. However, he cautioned, many New York Metropolis residents in communities affected by excessive crime don’t wish to eliminate the specialised items wholesale, even when their lively method generates criticism ties.

He pointed to the success of Eric Adams, a former NYPD captain who’s at the moment the main candidate within the mayoral race. Adams has campaigned on bringing again the controversial plainclothes Anti-Crime items to deal with gun violence in non-white, working class communities, that are his base.

“That’s the irony of the entire thing,” Giacalone stated. “You had the defund the police, anti-cop motion, and so they’re truly going to … watch for this… elect the ex-cop mayor.”

Papachristos, the Northwestern sociologist, contended that firing and disciplining drawback officers is a vital, however restricted step in direction of accountability. 

“Except we alter and deal with the problems that create these networks within the first place, we’re simply going to form of be repeating these kinds of patterns,” he stated.

George Joseph is a reporter with the WNYC/Gothamist Race & Justice Unit. You’ll be able to ship him tips about Fb, Twitter @georgejoseph94, Instagram @georgejoseph81, and at His cellphone and encrypted Sign app quantity is 929-486-4865.

Community visualizations by EJ Fox, an impartial information journalist whose work has been featured on CBS Information, the Washington Publish, NBC Information, MotherJones, and lots of different retailers.