Throughout a mayoral discussion board this week that centered on what varieties of state insurance policies the candidates would pursue in Albany, Metropolis Councilmember Carlos Menchaca, a left-leaning contender within the race, was requested how he would deal with working with Governor Andrew Cuomo.
The discussion board’s moderator Ben Max of Gotham Gazette, reminded Menchaca that within the 2018 gubernatorial election he endorsed Cuomo’s opponent, the actress-turned-progressive-activist Cynthia Nixon.
The candidate uneasily tried to sidestep the query, however Max did not let him off the hook. What would Menchaca do if he gained the first and Cuomo referred to as him? he requested. “Do you say ‘Wanting ahead to working with you’ or ‘be careful’?”
Menchaca chuckled and replied, “Each.”
The trade illustrated how the governor is looming over the New York Metropolis mayoral race, turning into a frequent query put to candidates as they marketing campaign their manner via a seemingly advert infinitum sequence of Zoom boards. In any yr, the facility the governor—and Cuomo, specifically—wields over town can’t be overstated. George Arzt, a political advisor who served as Mayor Ed Koch’s press secretary, stated that Cuomo as soon as advised him that the mayor of New York Metropolis “can’t go to the lavatory with out the state giving him permission.”
However as the following chief tries to spearhead town’s financial restoration, securing monetary assist and useful insurance policies in Albany will probably be extra crucial than ever. The following mayor’s relationship with Cuomo has arguably change into a fair better focus due to his coverage squabbles with Mayor Invoice de Blasio. In most of these cases, the governor has prevailed due to his overarching government authority.
“It’s helpful to think about Mayor de Blasio’s strategy as a textbook on what to not do,” stated David Birdsell, dean of the Baruch Faculty College of Public Affairs.
New York Metropolis mayors have traditionally battled with governors. Throughout his tenure, de Blasio has ceaselessly challenged Cuomo in areas he controls. Throughout the pandemic, he has publicly tried to stress the governor, who presently has emergency government energy, on every part from the vaccine rollout to shutdowns. The political tug-of-war has in some cases confused the general public, such because the second in April when the mayor introduced the closure of faculties for the remainder of the tutorial yr solely to have the governor shortly contradict him.
Extra lately, the 2 have battled over increasing vaccinations to extra teams of New Yorkers, resulting in their respective employees members airing out policy differences on Twitter.
The rupture between Cuomo and de Blasio is usually traced again to the mayor’s request for state funding for his common Pre-Ok plan. After stress from de Blasio, Cuomo granted him the funding.
“That ought to have been a cue for the mayor to say ‘thanks,'” stated Ester Fuchs, a professor at Columbia College’s College of Worldwide and Public Affairs who suggested prior mayors David Dinkins and Michael Bloomberg.
She added: “You must keep in mind persona and governing model and acknowledge that the governor has many of the playing cards.”
De Blasio, nonetheless, insisted on a millionaires’ tax although it was an election yr for Cuomo, who has ruled as a socially progressive tax-cutting Democrat.
In keeping with Arzt, “That is what prompted all the issues within the first place.”
Each Cuomo and de Blasio have repeatedly performed down their conflicts. And though they might appear uncommon, there have additionally been moments of unity. Kate Slevin, a senior vp for the Regional Plan Affiliation who works on transportation points in Albany, recalled when de Blasio and Cuomo strode collectively out of the governor’s workplace in 2019 to announce their help of congestion pricing. The picture was not misplaced on her and different transportation advocates. “To the extent that there might be agreed-upon proposals, it may speed up good insurance policies,” she stated.
As with so many different points, lots of the main candidates have gone out of their technique to criticize de Blasio’s strategy.
Each Metropolis Comptroller Scott Stringer and Brooklyn Borough President Eric Adams have argued that their previous expertise in Albany will assist them foyer the governor in addition to the legislature. Stringer served a state Assemblyman whereas Adams was a state Senator.
“Time and time once more, the mayor’s lunch cash was stolen even earlier than he walked into the state capital,” Stringer stated.
Particularly, Stringer stated he would begin by constructing a consensus amongst lawmakers in the course of the legislature’s off-session. He touted his relationships with progressives within the get together.
Of working with the governor, he stated: “That is about mutual respect.”
A few of the candidates have argued that they might be keen to let Cuomo occupy the highlight.
“You must acknowledge that there are occasions whenever you get what you need executed since you let the governor take credit score,” stated Maya Wiley, who labored as counsel to de Blasio, in the course of the discussion board.
Adams, in the meantime, stated he wouldn’t interact in public disputes with the governor and that they might have their disagreements behind closed doorways. “We can have a united entrance,” he stated.
And previous to coming down with coronavirus, Andrew Yang stated considerably obsequiously, “I’m keen to be a good friend and ally—and sidekick if needed—to the governor.”
In distinction, Dianne Morales, a progressive candidate, bluntly blamed Cuomo and “backroom offers” for town failing to perform its state legislative targets.
Who’s the opposition, @TweetBenMax asks Morales. She says Cuomo and Albany backroom offers. However she says she’s not opposed with constructing alliances and beginning conversations.
— Elizabeth Kim (@lizkimtweets) February 9, 2021
Birdsell stated that the following mayor’s relationship with the governor will depend upon their politics. A “hard-charging progressive,” he stated, is more likely to imply numerous coverage clashes over every part from hire rules to colleges to taxation to policing. In the meantime, a reasonable mayor “might have fewer built-in friction factors to barter, however will nonetheless have the problem of doing large issues with out defying or getting out too far forward of the Governor in areas that he controls,” he stated.
Fuchs stated that placing collectively a political coalition in Albany is notoriously tough for mayors.
“You are able to do every part proper and nonetheless lose,” she stated.
Cuomo himself has not weighed in on the race. His workplace didn’t reply to a request for remark.