City Says Jam-Packed Tompkins Square Park Hardcore Show Applied For Permit As “September 11 Memorial”


Final Saturday, hundreds of individuals packed into Tompkins Sq. Park for a free hardcore present that seems to have wound up being the most important city-permitted live performance in NYC for the reason that begin of the pandemic. The large crowd of largely maskless concertgoers left some questioning how the town allowed a present this massive to occur, when officers say COVID-19 stays a severe risk in NYC? However in line with the allow utility authorised by the Parks Division, this was by no means imagined to be a live performance—organizers had been given permission for a “September 11 Memorial” political rally.

The allow utility for “September 11 Memorial” was submitted on November 2nd, 2020 by organizer Chris Parker with an electronic mail related to The Shadow, an underground newspaper distributed on the Decrease East Facet. The Parks Division says that this group has booked occasions on the park since not less than 2006. The outline for this explicit occasion was listed as a “political rally with audio system and music,” in line with copies of paperwork shared with Gothamist.

Earlier this 12 months, the occasion date was switched to April twenty fourth, however the identify and outline of the occasion weren’t up to date.

Saturday’s live performance, which was organized by Black N’ Blue Productions, featured hardcore teams Madball, Murphy’s Regulation, Bloodclot and The Capturers; it was a free, unticketed occasion, however the bands solicited donations on GoFundMe beforehand for the New York Metropolis Burn Middle Basis (they raised over $6,000 altogether). 

In an announcement on Instagram, Black N’ Blue Productions denied that the occasion was listed as a 9/11 Memorial. However a replica of the allow utility supplied to Gothamist does determine the occasion as “September 11 Memorial.”

An excerpt from a permit application using the language "September 11th Memorial"


An excerpt from the allow utility.

“I’m positive most individuals know the media lies virtually on a regular basis,” Black N’ Blue Manufacturing’s assertion declares. “However only for shits and giggles the allow says nothing about 911 Memorial on it!! I’ve the allow in my hand. Fucking asshats. Had take a look at it once more to ensure however there’s nothing on it that claims 911 Memorial.”

The Parks Division advised Gothamist that a number of particulars concerning the nature of the occasion had been misrepresented, together with the truth that organizers acknowledged that 100 folks could be in attendance, not the two,000+ who confirmed up. The Parks Division mentioned that they “typically wouldn’t allow an occasion of this measurement on this park,” even when the town was not within the midst of a pandemic.

Organizers drove a automobile into the park, which a Parks Division spokesperson mentioned that they had not gotten permission to do; they introduced in a stage, which was not listed on the allow utility, and used amplified sound along side it; and the occasion was misrepresented to the Parks Division as a political rally, not a live performance, in line with the spokesperson.

However there have been moments in the course of the present the place performers did make political statements. At one level, Jimmy Gestapo, the lead singer of Murphy’s Regulation, in contrast masks to bondage (you may see video of that beneath). And after the present, Bloodclot frontman John Joseph responded to criticisms by evaluating the occasion to Black Lives Matter protests final 12 months.

Between the alleged misrepresentations and the truth that the occasion violated New York’s COVID-19 gathering restrictions by having too many individuals, no social distancing and lax masks carrying, Parks Division spokesperson Crystal Howard tells Gothamist, “We’re shifting to revoke all permits for this organizer and associated future occasions.”

Questions despatched to an electronic mail addressed listed on the allow utility weren’t answered previous to publication.

Altogether, the Parks Division has revoked permits for seven upcoming occasions by this organizer. That features two occasions that had already been authorised: one other hardcore present deliberate for Might eighth, that includes Antidote NYHC, Kings By no means Die, and the Final Stand, and a Memorial Day rally on Might twenty second. There have been 5 different pending occasions (all listed as “rallies” and all stating attendance could be 100 folks) revoked, together with a pair of dates commemorating the Tompkins Sq. Park Riot in August, and a Halloween Rally in October, in line with the Parks Division.

Spokespersons for Mayor Invoice de Blasio didn’t reply to questions concerning the occasion.

Meeting Member Harvey Epstein, who represents the Decrease East Facet, stumbled upon the live performance on Saturday whereas at one other occasion. “I noticed hordes and hordes of people that had been maskless with this live performance happening that was loopy,” he advised Gothamist. “It was insane, folks had been pouring into the streets, folks had been in every single place.”

Epstein mentioned he was shocked when he realized that the Parks Division had issued a allow, and he hopes officers are extra cautious about checking permits sooner or later.

“I would wish to see significantly better oversight by the Parks Division,” he mentioned. “If there’s a allow issued for an occasion, [I hope] that they really handle it and guarantee it is acceptable. If that they had seemed on the allow right here, they’d know they weren’t entitled to a stage and will have shut it down straight away.”