Brooklyn DA Will Purge 90 Convictions Involving An Indicted Detective, With 100 More Expected In Manhattan


Final week, Brooklyn District Lawyer Eric Gonzalez introduced he was shifting to dismiss 90 convictions involving Joseph Franco, an NYPD detective who was indicted in 2019 for mendacity below oath about three separate drug gross sales which he claimed to have witnessed. Now Manhattan District Lawyer Cyrus Vance has agreed to vacate and dismiss roughly 100 extra convictions through which Franco performed a key function, Gothamist/WNYC has realized.

The transfer comes almost two years after Manhattan prosecutors first introduced legal expenses in opposition to the previous NYPD detective, after discovering video footage allegedly exhibiting that three drug gross sales in Manhattan, which he swore to below oath, didn’t happen as he described them.

The announcement additionally comes sooner or later after the Authorized Help Society, the Exoneration Mission, and several other different organizations despatched a letter to District Lawyer Vance and Bronx District Lawyer Darcel Clark demanding they “vacate all convictions through which proof of guilt was purportedly obtained or produced” by Detective Franco.

Vance’s sweeping transfer, as soon as enacted, will symbolize one of many largest conviction purges in state historical past. And advocates are hoping for related motion from the Bronx District Lawyer’s Workplace.

Elizabeth Felber, a wrongful convictions legal professional with The Authorized Help Society, stated extra dismissals would sign to New Yorkers that conduct like Franco’s won’t be tolerated. “Prosecutors should play a elementary function holding police to account for misconduct, and we count on motion on this problem instantly,” she stated.

If Bronx prosecutors take the same step as their colleagues in Brooklyn and Manhattan, almost 300 convictions tied to a single detective could possibly be wiped away.

Bronx DA spokesperson Patrice O’Shaughnessy says that her workplace started its personal conviction overview two years in the past and has since recognized roughly 150 circumstances through which Detective Franco served as an undercover officer between 2011 and 2015, which resulted in conviction.

The unit will advocate the dismissal of all convictions the place Detective Franco performed an “important” function, in response to O’Shaughnessy. So far, the Bronx District Lawyer’s Conviction Integrity Unit has reviewed 116 of the circumstances through which Franco served as an undercover, and has present in most of them that he did play a key function.

Karen Newirth, a workers legal professional with The Exoneration Mission, one other signatory to the letter, argues the time-consuming nature of the DAs’ case-by-case opinions have denied dozens of New Yorkers crucial authorized reduction. As a substitute of spending time on the lookout for exonerating proof in years-old circumstances, resembling CCTV footage, she says, the perjury for which Franco was indicted ought to be sufficient to justify the immediate dismissal of all different convictions that relaxation upon his testimony.

“Of us who had been convicted based mostly on the phrase of Officer Franco each day endure the collateral penalties of their wrongful conviction,” Newirth stated. “Day-after-day, they’re unable to get jobs, they’re unable to get pupil loans, they might be unable to stay in and even go to household in public housing. They shouldn’t spend a further day, a lot much less a further 12 months or two years below the cloud of a wrongful conviction.”

Javian Torres is one in all dozens of Manhattan residents who Detective Franco arrested over the course of his profession.

In 2016, Torres says he and two mates had been hanging out in Tompkins Sq. Park once they had been approached by a person they thought was homeless providing them LSD. Torres, who was 16 on the time, stated they declined, however the man insisted. “He was like, ‘No, right here, simply take it, take it, attempt it. And for those who prefer it, I’ve extra,’” the Decrease East Aspect native remembers.

{The teenager} swallowed the capsule he says the person handed to him. A couple of minutes later, as the highschool college students had been about to take a seat down in one other a part of the park to smoke his pal’s joint, three plainclothes officers walked as much as them.

Two regarded misplaced carrying denims, polo shirts, and what Torres calls “beat-up cop sneakers.” However the third, a thin Hispanic man with a slight beard, was dressed for the half—designer garments, good sneakers, and a hat with colours to go along with the remainder of the outfit—Detective Joseph Franco.

“He was dressed properly, like anyone who you’d see within the neighborhood, who was in all probability doing one in all two issues, promoting medicine or [who] had a pleasant janitor job,” the Manhattan resident recollects.

Torres says Franco flashed his badge and began patting him down in opposition to a close-by gate. Because the detective was kicking his legs aside looking for medicine, Torres insisted he had nothing on him. That’s when, he says, the detective stated aloud, “I don’t care when you have something on you. You’re going to jail tonight.”

Torres did go to jail that evening, and was charged with a felony drug sale, an allegation which he says was fully false, “I didn’t have any medicine, cash, nothing.” Although his household was not rich, his mom discovered him a non-public legal professional and the case was ultimately dismissed.

At the moment, Torres has a steady job as a constructing porter and has stayed out of authorized bother. However the younger man, now 21, worries concerning the different folks whom Franco arrested and who weren’t so fortunate.

“This man is a detective in a narcotics unit whose phrase is meant to imply one thing,” he stated. “If this man is keen to arrest folks with no proof in any way simply because he already put the hassle into it, he simply needs to get the collar, that’s form of ridiculous. How are you going to belief the remainder of the legal justice system?”

Franco’s protection legal professional didn’t reply to repeated requests for remark about Torres’s claims or the pending legal indictment in opposition to him.

George Joseph reported this story for the Gothamist/WNYC Race & Justice Unit. You probably have a tip, or for those who work or have labored in a prosecutor’s workplace, a legislation enforcement company or the courts, e-mail reporter George Joseph at You can too textual content him ideas by way of the encrypted cellphone app Sign, or in any other case, at 929-486-4865.