Advocates Call Out Cuomo For Creating “COVID-Only” Nursing Homes And Not Telling Residents Or Families


Weak nursing house residents are being moved between services with little discover to households or elected officers, prompting considerations in regards to the Cuomo administration’s new technique to create “COVID-only” institutions. Whereas state officers say the coverage is required to maintain hospital beds open for acute-care sufferers, critics instructed Gothamist/WNYC the dearth of transparency suits a sample, one which prioritizes nursing houses over sufferers and their households.

Advocates and elected officers identified that a number of services taking in COVID-positive sufferers discharged from hospitals have poor scores, together with one nursing house that has spent greater than 5 years on a federal watch checklist for a number of the worst nursing houses within the nation.

“The general public and I, as chair of the Meeting Well being Committee, don’t actually know something about this,” stated Assemblymember Richard Gottfried. “It’s troubling and it’s sadly a reasonably frequent scenario with the Cuomo administration.”

Earlier this yr, after an investigation by Lawyer Basic Letitia James and mounting strain from lawmakers, prime officers within the Cuomo administration admitted they obscured the information on nursing house deaths by not together with the practically 4,000 nursing house residents who died in hospitals. Gottfried stated the most recent lack of transparency in regards to the COVID-only nursing houses prompt they haven’t modified their methods, including that he doesn’t have an issue with this system itself.

“They may inform us day-after-day inside hours exactly how many individuals they are saying received vaccinated yesterday. However loads of data they refuse to provide out or generally refuse to say they’ve.” Gottfried famous. “I do not suppose I’ve skilled this type of wall-to-wall secrecy coverage in a governor beforehand. And, you recognize, I’ve served with eight governors, in order that’s saying one thing.”

State officers instructed WNYC/Gothamist the transfer was wanted to maintain hospital beds open for acute-care sufferers. Initially, 19 nursing houses have been designated COVID-only, with some services setting apart a wing or a unit and others a complete constructing. Due to a decline in COVID circumstances, well being officers decreased the quantity to 13. As of March tenth, 36% of hospital beds have been out there within the state.

“Ought to charges of COVID prevalence rise, we’re ready to and can work to re-establish extra COVID-only nursing houses as wanted,” a Division of Well being spokesman wrote in a press release. “Nursing houses are required beneath state and federal legal guidelines and laws to simply accept solely these residents for whom they will present applicable care.”

Past poor communication in regards to the new coverage, critics instructed Gothamist/WNYC they have been fearful about residents who have been moved haphazardly to low-rated services to make room for Covid sufferers who’ve the potential to usher in extra funds as a result of Medicaid reimburses houses at a better charge for his or her care.

One resident of a long-term facility, who spoke on situation of anonymity for worry of retaliation, stated he was given lower than 24 hours warning earlier than he was moved. He had lived at Seaside Gardens Nursing and Rehab Heart in Far Rockaway, Queens for 12 years.

“They instructed me to pack and that was it. The following day I used to be moved out,” the person instructed us, including that on the new facility he was in he noticed residents strolling the halls with out masks and crowded circumstances. He stated he was put in a room with three different folks.

“I did not come from one place to return to this place to get sick or get one thing,” he stated. “I used to be scared. I used to be very, very scared.”

The person had moved from a four-star facility, as decided by the federal authorities, to a two-star facility, each run by the identical proprietor. After complaining for a number of weeks and contacting the state well being division, the person was transferred to a 3rd facility, with a four-star score, additionally owned by the identical operator.

Seaside Gardens didn’t reply to a request for remark. Final month workers from the ability protested the nursing house’s conversion to a COVID-only facility.

WNYC/Gothamist realized of this one man’s story as a result of he works with a company referred to as the Heart for Independence of the Disabled NY, which tracked him down after he was out of the blue moved from his Far Rockaway house. Susan Dooha, government director of CIDNY, stated three different shoppers have been transferred to make room for COVID sufferers—workers haven’t been capable of find two of them.

“Right here we’re in New York Metropolis in 2021 and it is potential to vanish folks in the event that they’re older or if they’ve disabilities,” Dooha stated. “With actually no management in anyway, no residence rights, no capacity to complain or attraction or say no, that is a very inhuman factor to do to somebody.”

A spokesperson for the state well being division declined to say what protections have been in place to make sure residents weren’t transferred into services that have been unsafe or inappropriate for them. Additionally they wouldn’t say why services with poor scores from the federal authorities could be appropriate to take care of COVID-19 sufferers.

“There are at present 13 varied various services, with a big variety of beds appropriate for COVID-positive nursing house sufferers,” they stated in a press release. “These services, in coordination with native well being methods and native governments, supplied to voluntarily convert to COVID-only on a brief foundation. Every operator and facility was vetted towards a backdrop of neighborhood want, high quality and infection-control protocols, and operational capacity.”

But it surely’s been properly documented that Cayuga Ridge Prolonged Care is a troubled nursing house with a protracted historical past of issues. In line with an inspection report in June of 2019, it had 27 deficiencies. The common variety of deficiencies in New York State is 5.2. In October, well being officers discovered the nursing house didn’t “present and implement an an infection prevention and management program.”

Cayuga didn’t return a telephone name searching for remark; it’s unclear what number of COVID sufferers are at present beneath its care.

Richard Mollot, an advocate for residents of long-term care services and director of the Lengthy Time period Care Group Coalition, stated the Cuomo administration as soon as once more failed to contemplate the well-being of nursing house residents when implementing coverage. He pointed to Cayuga, a one-star facility on a federal watch checklist as a stark instance.

“There’s actually no oversight or planning to guarantee that, once more, that the services which can be chosen are good and applicable and assembly the minimal requirements of care,” Mollot stated. “And the identical goes for the services to which individuals are being despatched.”

One other facility on the state checklist with a low score, the New Jewish Residence, instructed Gothamist/WNYC that the federal score system for nursing houses was problematic. The federal authorities gave the Manhattan facility an total two-star score, and just one star relating to well being inspections.

Jeffrey Farber, director of The New Jewish Residence, stated the house has taken 174 COVID sufferers transferred from hospitals to this point, and he defended the standard of care they’ve obtained

“We have had now seven infection-control targeted prevention surveys by the Division of Well being over these many months, and all of them have been completely superb, deficiency-free,” he stated.

The non-profit nursing house on West 106th road remoted COVID sufferers in considered one of their three buildings. Farber stated he had the room as a result of many former residents died from COVID and no new residents arrived to switch them. He stated the choice to soak up COVID sufferers was not motivated by monetary acquire, though he acknowledged that the ability operated with a deficit, a monetary actuality that existed previous to the pandemic.

“So whether or not we’ll find yourself higher or not, I am probably not certain,” he stated. “But it surely’s actually the appropriate factor to do to handle folks.”

The services on the COVID-only checklist may obtain a 50% p.c enhance in Medicaid reimbursement, one thing Gottfried stated was cheap so long as the additional cash goes towards affected person care. However he warned that nursing houses, notably for-profit services, typically spend a small fraction of their income on sufferers. Farber stated the bump solely kicks in after 100 days and by then most sufferers can have recovered and moved on.

Farber stated he’s needed to rent extra workers, construct a brand new entrance, and outfit staff with protecting tools to securely take care of COVID sufferers. He stated nursing houses have been unfairly blamed and scapegoated all through the pandemic.

“It’s been a protracted, type of demoralizing yr in some ways,” he stated. “I imply, it is a pandemic and we’re on the entrance traces.”

Extra reporting from Afia Eama